MARCELLO’S Restaurant.
Fresh pasta. Seafood. Steak. Homemade desserts. Beer, wine, and cocktails. Everything made with care, served with warmth. Dine in, order takeout, or let us cater your next event.
A wood-fired oven that rarely cools, pasta rolled out before service every day, seafood that arrives wild, and a pastry team that believes dessert is the best part of dinner. The same recipes since 2002 — sharper now.
Our pizzas are made in a wood-fired oven using San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and dough that is stretched by hand daily. The wood fire gives each pie a perfectly blistered crust with a subtle smokiness that you cannot get from a conventional oven. From the classic Margherita to the truffle-topped Tartufo, every pizza is made to order.
Our pasta is not shipped in from a warehouse. It is made fresh in our kitchen every day. The Lobster Rigatoni, the Tagliatelle Bolognese, the Linguini Carbonara — these are the dishes our regulars come back for week after week. Paired with sauces made from scratch using imported Italian ingredients, every plate is the real thing.
Beyond pizza and pasta, our menu features wild-caught Branzino, Salmon Piccata, Seafood Linguini Fra Diavolo, Chicken Scarpariello, Veal Marsala, and more. Each dish is prepared to order by Chef Ernesto and his team, with an attention to balance and seasonality that defines the room.
End the night right with our homemade Tiramisu, Molten Chocolate Cake served with vanilla ice cream, classic Panna Cotta, or a freshly filled Cannoli. All made in-house, all worth ordering with a second espresso.
A neighborhood restaurant in the best sense of the word.
— On Fifth Avenue since 2002
Marcello’s is a family-style Italian restaurant at 33 Fifth Avenue in the heart of Pelham, New York. Whether it is a weeknight dinner with the family, a date night over cocktails, or a Saturday afternoon pizza with friends, we have been the place this town comes back to.
Diner’s Choice winner in both 2024 and 2025 — a reflection of what guests have come to expect: great food, attentive service, and a dining room that feels like home.
Read our storyEven better than the pizza I had in Italy.
✦ ❦ ✦
Reserve a table, order takeout, or get delivery — we’ll bring Marcello’s to your night.